58 Wilbur Street

A — 99.5

STATEN ISLAND · Wilbur Street · Zip 10309

At 58 Wilbur Street, Staten Island, the excellent grade of A (99.5) reflects its spotless crime record, but a single missed collection and recycling issue hint at minor maintenance oversight.

Street-wide 311 complaints trend → Stable

Building Details

Owner

CARINA AMATO, TRUSTEE

Building Class

Units

2 units

Year Built

2003

Complaints

1 total · 0.5 complaints/unit

City Council District

District 51

Transit Access

Transit Score

Fair

Nearest Subway

Prince's Bay

1232 m

Lines

SIR

Nearest Bus Stop

HYLAN BLVD/SEGUINE AV

470 m

Bus Route

SIM2

Should you live here? A — 99.5

🔇

Noise

●●●○○

Average

🐀

Pests

●●●○○

Average

🔒

Safety

●●●○○

Average

🏠

Maintenance

●●●○○

Average

🧹

Cleanliness

●●●○○

Average

Noise
complaints

Rodent/
pest issues

Felonies
nearby

Total
311 issues

311 Complaints at this address

Category	Count
Dirty/Trash	1
Total	1

Crime near this address

Category	Count
Felonies	0
Misdemeanors	0
Violations	0
Total	0

Other buildings on Wilbur Street

19 Wilbur Street 86.8 73 Wilbur Street 98.5 25 Wilbur Street 98.7 16 Wilbur Street 99.2 69 Wilbur Street 99.3 5 Wilbur Street 99.5 11 Wilbur Street 99.5 18 Wilbur Street 99.6 54 Wilbur Street 99.6 21 Wilbur Street 99.7 37 Wilbur Street 99.7 3 Wilbur Street 99.7 41 Wilbur Street 99.8

Nearby streets

Melville Street 93.6 Walch Place 97.1 Van Wyck Avenue 99.1 Case Avenue 83.6 Norman Place 96.1

Add your comment

Share your experience living at this address or rate the neighborhood.

Data from NYC 311 and NYPD. Last updated 2026.