58 South Street

A — 99.7

STATEN ISLAND · South Street · Zip 10310

At 58 South Street, Staten Island, an 'A' grade (99.7) suggests excellent conditions, with only a single water system complaint, a running hydrant, and no recent crime activity nearby.

Street-wide 311 complaints trend ↑ Increasing

Street-wide Crime trend 31 total

Building Details

Owner

MORDOR LLC

Building Class

Units

1 unit

Year Built (pre-war)

1899

Complaints

1 total · 1.0 complaints/unit

City Council District

District 49

Transit Access

100

Transit Score

Excellent

Nearest Subway

Stapleton

3500 m

Lines

SIR

Nearest Bus Stop

CARY AV/BROADWAY

89 m

Bus Route

S44

Should you live here? A — 99.7

🔇

Noise

●●●○○

Average

🐀

Pests

●●●○○

Average

🔒

Safety

●●●○○

Average

🏠

Maintenance

●●●○○

Average

🧹

Cleanliness

●●●○○

Average

Noise
complaints

Rodent/
pest issues

Felonies
nearby

Total
311 issues

311 Complaints at this address

Category	Count
Water/Sewer	1
Total	1

Crime near this address

Category	Count
Felonies	0
Misdemeanors	0
Violations	0
Total	0

Other buildings on South Street

44 South Street 94.6 4 South Street 96.7 43 South Street 98.0 52 South Street 98.1 40 South Street 98.2 37 South Street 98.6 50 South Street 98.6 31 South Street 98.7 17 South Street 98.9 41 South Street 99.0 47 South Street 99.0 28 South Street 99.0 15 South Street 99.0 56 South Street 99.2 51 South Street 99.4 27 South Street 99.4 30 South Street 99.4 38 South Street 99.4 29 South Street 99.8

Nearby streets

Britton Street 53.0 Broadway 0 State Street 93.7 Seneca Street 15.4 West Street 46.5

Add your comment

Share your experience living at this address or rate the neighborhood.

Data from NYC 311 and NYPD. Last updated 2026.