58 Holly Street

A — 99.4

STATEN ISLAND · Holly Street · Zip 10304

At 58 Holly Street, Staten Island, this A-grade property (score: 99.4) boasts exceptional safety with zero recent felonies or misdemeanors, yet faces minor water issues, including one report of no water and another of low pressure.

Street-wide 311 complaints trend → Stable

Building Details

Owner

C MERICKO

Building Class

Units

1 unit

Year Built (pre-war)

1935

Complaints

2 total · 2.0 complaints/unit

City Council District

District 50

Transit Access

100

Transit Score

Excellent

Nearest Subway

Old Town

721 m

Lines

SIR

Entrances within 1km

Nearest Bus Stop

RICHMOND RD/ROME AV

261 m

Bus Route

SIM15

Should you live here? A — 99.4

🔇

Noise

●●●○○

Average

🐀

Pests

●●●○○

Average

🔒

Safety

●●●○○

Average

🏠

Maintenance

●●●○○

Average

🧹

Cleanliness

●●●○○

Average

Noise
complaints

Rodent/
pest issues

Felonies
nearby

Total
311 issues

311 Complaints at this address

Category	Count
Water/Sewer	2
Total	2

Crime near this address

Category	Count
Felonies	0
Misdemeanors	0
Violations	0
Total	0

Other buildings on Holly Street

2 Holly Street 97.7 11 Holly Street 98.9 116 Holly Street 98.9 15 Holly Street 99.2 127 Holly Street 99.5 1 Holly Street 99.5 94 Holly Street 99.5 70 Holly Street 99.5 88 Holly Street 99.5 14 Holly Street 99.6 22 Holly Street 99.6 77 Holly Street 99.6 10 Holly Street 99.7 66 Holly Street 99.7 97 Holly Street 99.7 78 Holly Street 99.7 85 Holly Street 99.7 44 Holly Street 99.7 62 Holly Street 99.7

Nearby streets

Sparkill Avenue 89.8 Sparkhill Avenue 76.4 Mason Street 46.8 Mountainside Road 99.2 Hunton Street 91.5

Add your comment

Share your experience living at this address or rate the neighborhood.

Data from NYC 311 and NYPD. Last updated 2026.