NYC Report Card
NYC / STATEN ISLAND / Old Mill Road / 40 Old Mill Road

40 Old Mill Road

A — 99.6

STATEN ISLAND · Old Mill Road · Zip 10306

← Back to Old Mill Road

At 40 Old Mill Road, Staten Island, this A-grade property (score: 99.6) boasts safety with zero recent felonies or misdemeanors, yet faces minor maintenance issues like a fallen tree and broken sidewalk.

Street-wide 311 complaints trend → Stable

Street-wide Crime trend 2 total

Building Details

Owner
CHURCH OF ST ANDREW
Building Class
M3
Units
1 unit
Year Built (pre-war)
1931
Complaints
2 total · 2.0 complaints/unit
City Council District
District 51

Transit Access

66
Transit Score
Good
Nearest Subway
Bay Terrace
2055 m
Lines
SIR
Nearest Bus Stop
ARTHUR KILL RD/CENTER ST
155 m
Bus Route
S74

Should you live here? A — 99.6

🔇
Noise
●●●○○
Average
🐀
Pests
●●●○○
Average
🔒
Safety
●●●○○
Average
🏠
Maintenance
●●●○○
Average
🧹
Cleanliness
●●●○○
Average
0
Noise
complaints
0
Rodent/
pest issues
0
Felonies
nearby
2
Total
311 issues

311 Complaints at this address

CategoryCount
Street Condition1
Trees/Outdoor1
Total2

Crime near this address

CategoryCount
Felonies0
Misdemeanors0
Violations0
Total0

Other buildings on Old Mill Road

453 Old Mill Road 95.3 447 Old Mill Road 97.9 481 Old Mill Road 99.5 483 Old Mill Road 99.7 463 Old Mill Road 99.8 457 Old Mill Road 99.8

Nearby streets

Franklin Lane 96.9 St Patricks Place 99.5 Chess Loop 94.7 Newvale Avenue 99.6 Rigby Avenue 99.6

Add your comment

Share your experience living at this address or rate the neighborhood.

Data from NYC 311 and NYPD. Last updated 2026.