186 Shiel Avenue

A — 97.3

STATEN ISLAND · Shiel Avenue · Zip 10309

At 186 Shiel Avenue in Staten Island, you'll find a well-maintained property with minimal complaints (only 13 in total), earning it an A grade. However, it struggles with persistent illegal parking issues, particularly improper parking permit use.

Street-wide 311 complaints trend → Stable

Building Details

Owner

MICHAEL ROTUNNO

Building Class

Units

1 unit

Year Built

1995

Complaints

13 total · 13.0 complaints/unit

City Council District

District 51

Transit Access

Transit Score

Excellent

Nearest Subway

Pleasant Plains

2429 m

Lines

SIR

Nearest Bus Stop

BLOOMINGDALE RD/SHIEL AV

77 m

Bus Route

S74

Should you live here? A — 97.3

🔇

Noise

●●●●●

Very quiet

🐀

Pests

●●●●●

Clean

🔒

Safety

●●●●●

Very safe

🏠

Maintenance

●●●●●

Excellent

🧹

Cleanliness

●●●●●

Spotless

Noise
complaints

Rodent/
pest issues

Felonies
nearby

Total
311 issues

311 Complaints at this address

Category	Count
Parking/Traffic	12
Street Condition	1
Total	13

Crime near this address

Category	Count
Felonies	0
Misdemeanors	0
Violations	0
Total	0

Other buildings on Shiel Avenue

193 Shiel Avenue 95.8 192 Shiel Avenue 98.6 201 Shiel Avenue 98.7 149 Shiel Avenue 98.9 10 Shiel Avenue 99.0 195 Shiel Avenue 99.1 23 Shiel Avenue 99.1 131 Shiel Avenue 99.2 137 Shiel Avenue 99.3 22 Shiel Avenue 99.4 151 Shiel Avenue 99.5 194 Shiel Avenue 99.6 198 Shiel Avenue 99.7 5 Shiel Avenue 99.7 185 Shiel Avenue 99.8 12 Shiel Avenue 99.8 21 Shiel Avenue 99.8 118 Shiel Avenue 99.8 158 Shiel Avenue 99.8

Nearby streets

Malvine Avenue 81.7 Veterans Road East 72.9 Ashley Lane 94.4 Sandywood Lane 92.9 Candon Avenue 79.2

Add your comment

Share your experience living at this address or rate the neighborhood.

Data from NYC 311 and NYPD. Last updated 2026.