NYC Report Card
NYC / STATEN ISLAND / Bay Street / 1251 Bay Street

1251 Bay Street

A — 99.2

STATEN ISLAND · Bay Street · Zip 10305

← Back to Bay Street

"1251 Bay Street in Staten Island boasts an impressive A grade (99.2), with just one plumbing complaint and no recent crime incidents nearby, indicating a well-maintained and safe environment."

Street-wide 311 complaints trend → Stable

Building Details

Owner
GOMEZ, ALEXANDER
Building Class
A1
Units
1 unit
Year Built (pre-war)
1901
Complaints
1 total · 1.0 complaints/unit
City Council District
District 49

Transit Access

76
Transit Score
Excellent
Nearest Subway
Clifton
997 m
Lines
SIR
Entrances within 1km
3
Nearest Bus Stop
BAY ST/HYLAN BLVD
116 m
Bus Route
S51

Should you live here? A — 99.2

🔇
Noise
●●●○○
Average
🐀
Pests
●●●○○
Average
🔒
Safety
●●●○○
Average
🏠
Maintenance
●●●○○
Average
🧹
Cleanliness
●●●○○
Average
0
Noise
complaints
0
Rodent/
pest issues
0
Felonies
nearby
1
Total
311 issues

311 Complaints at this address

CategoryCount
Maintenance1
Total1

Crime near this address

CategoryCount
Felonies0
Misdemeanors0
Violations0
Total0

Other buildings on Bay Street

194 Bay Street 0 475 Bay Street 0 722 Bay Street 58.1 533 Bay Street 66.7 1331 Bay Street 70.2 977 Bay Street 74.5 192 Bay Street 75.1 200 Bay Street 77.6 330 Bay Street 78.6 442 Bay Street 79.3 646 Bay Street 79.4 35 Bay Street 81.7 195 Bay Street 83.5 996 Bay Street 86.7 639 Bay Street 87.7 364 Bay Street 88.5 585 Bay Street 91.0 1236 Bay Street 91.4 155 Bay Street 91.5 845 Bay Street 92.1

Nearby streets

White Street 60.3 Keeley Street 89.0 Abbott Street 96.7 New Lane 62.3 Scarboro Avenue 71.5

Add your comment

Share your experience living at this address or rate the neighborhood.

Data from NYC 311 and NYPD. Last updated 2026.