NYC Report Card
NYC / BROOKLYN / East 51 Street / 458 East 51 Street

458 East 51 Street

F — 8.5

BROOKLYN · East 51 Street · Zip 11203

← Back to East 51 Street

The building at 458 East 51st Street in Brooklyn received an F grade with 8.5 points, indicating significant issues. The most pressing concerns are unsanitary conditions and heat/hot water problems, with 22 and 18 complaints respectively.

Street-wide 311 complaints trend ↓ Decreasing

Street-wide Crime trend 59 total

Building Details

Owner
MARCEL BAPTISTE
Building Class
B3
Units
2 units
Year Built (pre-war)
1901
Complaints
92 total · 46.0 complaints/unit
City Council District
District 45

Noise Breakdown

What kind of noise is being reported?

Music/Party
6
86%
Neighbors
0
0%
Construction
0
0%
Traffic/Cars
0
0%
Other Noise
0
0%

Transit Access

100
Transit Score
Excellent
Nearest Subway
Sutter Av-Rutland Rd
1669 m
Lines
3
Nearest Bus Stop
UTICA AV/SNYDER AV
75 m
Bus Route
B46

Should you live here? F — 8.5

🔇
Noise
●●●○○
Average
🐀
Pests
●●●○○
Average
🔒
Safety
●●●○○
Average
🏠
Maintenance
●●●○○
Average
🧹
Cleanliness
●●●○○
Average
7
Noise
complaints
24
Rodent/
pest issues
0
Felonies
nearby
92
Total
311 issues

311 Complaints at this address

CategoryCount
Maintenance52
Rodents/Pests24
Noise7
Safety4
Dirty/Trash2
Street Condition1
Air Quality1
Other1
Total92

Crime near this address

CategoryCount
Felonies0
Misdemeanors0
Violations0
Total0

Other buildings on East 51 Street

1271 East 51 Street 16.6 140 East 51 Street 47.0 210 East 51 Street 47.7 155 East 51 Street 72.3 340 East 51 Street 72.8 240 East 51 Street 75.4 522 East 51 Street 75.8 350 East 51 Street 76.9 100 East 51 Street 83.9 1270 East 51 Street 84.0 455 East 51 Street 85.9 412 East 51 Street 86.0 36 East 51 Street 86.0 1462 East 51 Street 86.4 490 East 51 Street 86.6 188 East 51 Street 86.8 173 East 51 Street 88.0 306 East 51 Street 88.6 170 East 51 Street 89.6

Nearby streets

Utica Avenue 0 Schnectady Avenue 68.4 East 47 Street 99.5 Schenectady Avenue 0 East 52 Street 0

Add your comment

Share your experience living at this address or rate the neighborhood.

Data from NYC 311 and NYPD. Last updated 2026.